Google and The Mathematics of History

Seems like whenever I think of something interesting to write, one way or the other, it ends up being related to Google.  I am developing a fascination with what they can do with all the data they are collecting.  I am becoming to Google, what Dr. Hugo Strange was to Batman, a psychologist, so consumed by analyzing Batman that he ends up trying to be Batman.  But I digress…

Before we get to Google, I have to tell you about Anatoly T. Fomenko, a Russian Mathematician, who makes the bold claim that the timing of historical events, Chronology, as we know it is wrong (Sir Isaac Newton makes this claim in a paper too).  Fomenko asserts that history is off by about 1000 years.  Cultures we think to have existed say 200BC is actually 800 AD.  Ancient Egypt, ancient Rome all existed but a lot later than we have come to believe.  More specifically, the claim is that the clergy in the 16th and 17th centuries duplicated medieval European history into biblical history.  Documents describing the life of kings of ancient Rome are actually documents describing German kinds in 1300.  The most controversial claim that falls out is that Jesus Christ was born somewhere near year 1000.  Before you guys go “no friggin way, you’ve watched the Da Vinci Code too many times”, let me be the first to say that I am not interested about the accuracy of the claims.  You can buy the book here, and form an opinion on it yourself (but I warn you, this is heavy heavy reading).  What I am very much interested is what gave Fomenko the initial idea, and the methodology by which Fomenko reaches his claims.

The initial idea comes from analyzing lunar eclipses.  There are working laws of physics that allow astronomers to predict exactly when and where on the world an eclipse will happen.  We get news of this all the time.  They can go backwards in time as well, and match all the recorded eclipses to what the theory predicts.  But Fomenko notices (in the works of astronomer Robert Newton) a serious mismatch.  Eclipses that were recorded to have happened between 700-1300 AD show lunar behavior that vastly differs from theory and could only be explained by a mysterious non-gravitational force applied on the earth-moon system.  However, this mysterious force completely disappears, and everything matches theory, if the dates of the eclipses were wrong and each one actually about 1000 years later than claimed.  This surprises Fomenko and he gets obsessed with analyzing chronology. 

But he’s a lot smarter than many of us, and devises a statistical method that can determine whether two pieces of text are written in the same time period.  Now this is very important, and touches the crux of what I am talking about.  Language changes over time.  The words we use change.  New words are added and some words disappear.  The kinds of sentences we construct change over time, and all those changes can be quantified.  In a way, the syntax of a document, not its semantics, can be used to determine when it is written.  This sounds reasonable and acceptable mathematically.  As a result, Fomenko takes a documents said to be written in the times of ancient Rome, and compares it to a documents many years later and concludes that they are statistically from the same time period.  There are chapters and chapters comparing kings of ancient Rome to kings of Germany, saying that these two kings were actually the same person.  This sounds very reasonable and acceptable mathematically, but accepting is socially is another matter.  To make it socially acceptable, the mathematics needs to be extremely accurate.  Can it be?  Is there a company out there who has the computing power, the smarts, to take vast amounts of text data and analyze it statistically?

Enter Google.  They have more data and computing power than Anatoly Fomenko could have ever imagined having.  So can this statistical method be improved to get the time interval more and more accurate?  Can they date text to within 50 years, 10 years, 2 years?  This kind of statistics could shed a lot of light into what historical document is fake, what document is real.  It would solve a lot of the world’s problems about how history really happened.  Google can, in effect, take history from the hands of historians, and place it in the hands of mathematicians.  And that my friends, would be an earth shattering event.  Only Google could do this.  It would start a whole different way of debating history, one which is more scientific and less ideological.   This is a big big step towards organizing the worlds information.

There was a time in history where it was unheard of to discuss human origins in biology class.  Who knows, maybe in the near future, human history will be taught in statistics class?

Comments

[Cem Sertoglu]

I had never heard of this theory. Fascinating!

[Vik]

I am exposed to more fascinating ideas from reading this blog than I ever did in two years of business school.

[baris]

Vik,
Your comment will undoubtedly mislead my readers into thinking that you went to HBS.

[Koray C]

Very interesting. My first question would be if the velocity of change in the language is constant throughout the history. I would expect the change in the past to be at a relatively modest rate (in the same time frame) hence no significant change between the texts of the Roman kings and the German kings. Advanced technology leads to increasing level of collaboration and greater community which I assume should accelarate the change. My two cents.

[buy propecia]

I really like this blog, you are very good making them. I say that the issue discussed in this blog is quite interesting and of high quality.

[Kamagra]

I like this article because it talks about different Mathematics and genius of the History I feel so identify because I'm studying math and it has been complicated for me so I'm gonna try to get the knowledge those men had to be successful.

[Viagra Online]

Very good blog, and is interesting that this person every time that he wants to write something it has to be with Google, is that where it goes the evolution?

[zygor guides]

wow great i have read many articles about this topic and everytime i learn something new i dont think it will ever stop always new info , Thanks for all of your hard work!

[Buy kamagra oral jelly 100mg]

Great piece of article. It explains so much about the topic. I should say it is a detailed article. Talks about a variety of things - something which I never thought could exist. What I found different in your article is the way you have gone about to explain the topic in a simplistic way.

[Generic Viagra]

Nice and very informative information. I had just got a tip off the last time from my friend regarding this blog, today I thought I should go for the trial and guess what this trial search for the blog worked very well. I am happy I opened up the article and read it.

[Buy Kamagra]

Great article

[zenegra online]

HI,
Nice and interesting information posted about Google and The Mathematics of History.Really very interesting..
Thanks for posting this blog..

[temporary internet miami]

awesome blog, interesting theory, I'm tempted to buy that book even is heavy heavy reading.... awesome thanks for the information

[temporary internet miami]

It is very interesting topic you've written here..The truth I'm not related to this, but I think is a good opportunity to learn more about it… And as well talk about a different topic to which I used to talk with others..

[MBA Colleges in Mumbai]

Hey hi...ijust go through your post.it's really awesome. i think here is the place where people can share their knowledge easily. Thank you for sharing such a nice Information.

[website]

It comes along very well. Both are measured perfectly.

[purchase hard on oral jelly]

Alternative Buying Portland with no prescription being treated with anticonvulsants Sumycin Find no prescriptions online without prescription online FedEx cod overnight pain on swallowing To Get online without prescription.Cod U.S. - Special internet prices cataracts or impaired eyesight Sumycin cheape online taking metronidazole or paraldehyde Sale cheap US cod no prescription +FREE Pills.Buying discounted Atlanta no Prescr's needed +FREE Tabs high blood pressure Levaquin FREE SAMPLES!Cheapest USA Discount Drug Shop
buy Levaquin, buy Nexium, buy Lioresal,

[Account Deleted]

Nice Post amazing information and attractive, I like your way of thinking keep on sharing good things to your friends.

the best seo company

[Carpet Cleaning London]

I am really glad that you have take your time to write a good and informative article as this piece I am reading now. I will check out the stuff you have in your side. Sincerely: a reader

[hgundpgucc]

http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-patent-expiration plavix patent expiration
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-with-prilosec plavix with prilosec
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-tablet plavix tablet
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-indications plavix indications
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-mechanism-of-action plavix mechanism of action

[zlvttjvikp]

http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-75-mg-price-in-india plavix 75 mg price in india
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/buy-plavix-online buy plavix online
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com plavix coupon
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix plavix
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-generic plavix generic

[mgncxzgkra]

http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-45-mg plavix 45 mg
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-60-mg plavix 60 mg
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-medication-guide plavix medication guide
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-300-mg-daily plavix 300 mg daily
http://plavix-coupon.posterous.com/plavix-not-working plavix not working

[moncler shop]

let's join our hands together to stop this kind of wrong doings. It may risk lives in the future if we just let them continue.

[skip hire prices]

This is really a good post about so interesting comparison between Google and its mathematical history. You presented very good facts.